Many trademark refusals by the Directorate General of Intellectual Property (DJKI), known locally as pendaftaran merek ditolak, can be predicted before you file an application.
Key takeaways
- Indonesia follows a first-to-file system. Trademark rights arise from registration, not from who used the mark first.
- Refusals fall into two groups: marks that cannot be registered because of their nature (Article 20 of the Trademark Law) and marks refused because they conflict with others’ rights (Article 21).
- Searching the DJKI database and honestly assessing distinctiveness before filing prevents most refusals.
Legal basis
Law No. 20 of 2016 on Marks and Geographical Indications, as amended through the Job Creation framework, governs trademark registration, and DJKI administers it. A registered mark is protected for 10 years from the filing date and can be renewed for the same period.
Group one: marks that cannot be registered
Article 20 sets out marks that cannot be registered because of the nature of the sign itself, whether or not anyone else has a similar mark. The most common in practice:
- Lack of distinctiveness. Signs that are too simple, or merely common words, cannot distinguish your goods or services from others’.
- Signs that are the same as, relate to, or simply name the goods or services. For example, “Tasty Coffee” for coffee. Words describing type, quality or function are hard to register.
- Misleading elements about origin, quality, type or benefit.
- Generic names or public symbols, and signs contrary to state ideology, law, morality, religion, decency or public order.
Group two: conflicts with others’ rights
Article 21 covers refusals based on other marks or rights. The most frequent ground is similarity in essence or in whole with a registered mark, or an earlier application, for similar goods or services. Similarity in essence does not require identical marks: similar sound, appearance or dominant elements can be enough.
Other grounds include similarity with a well-known mark, including for dissimilar goods in certain circumstances; similarity with a registered geographical indication; use of another person’s name, photograph or company name without consent; imitation of state or official emblems; and applications filed in bad faith, for example registering a mark known to belong to someone else abroad.
Common mistakes
- Choosing a descriptive mark because customers remember it. Memorable is not the same as protectable.
- Searching only for identical words. Searches should cover spelling variants, translations and similar-sounding marks.
- Choosing the wrong classes. Protection applies only to the registered classes. Businesses selling goods and services often need more than one.
- Waiting until the product is known. Under first-to-file, someone else can file first.
- Ignoring the publication period. After formal examination, the application is published, and third parties can oppose it. Brand owners can also use publication to oppose others’ similar applications.
If an application is refused
DJKI issues a proposed refusal with reasons, and the applicant can respond. If the refusal is maintained, the applicant can appeal to the Trademark Appeals Commission and then to the Commercial Court. Effective responses compare the dominant elements of both marks, the differences in goods or services and the target consumers, rather than simply asserting that the marks are different.
Checks before filing
- Search DJKI’s intellectual property database for the same word, spelling variants and similar sounds in relevant classes.
- Test distinctiveness: does the sign merely describe the product?
- Choose all classes relevant to your business plans for the next two to three years.
- Make sure the applicant is the right party, normally the company that will use the mark rather than a founder personally, unless deliberately chosen.
- Keep evidence of the mark’s creation and use in case of opposition.
ReksaLegal assists with trademark searches, applications and responses to proposed refusals. Contact us at reksalegal.com or admin@reksalegal.com.
Legal references: Law No. 20 of 2016 on Marks and Geographical Indications (incl. Arts. 20, 21, 35) as amended by Law No. 6 of 2023. Position as at 23 October 2026. Author: Sri Purnama.
General information only, not legal advice.