Indonesia-focused business legal and regulatory services · South Tangerang, Banten admin@reksalegal.com WhatsApp +62 878-8636-0462

Contracts & Corporate

Shareholders’ Agreement or Articles of Association: Which Prevails When They Conflict?

Founders negotiating a perjanjian pemegang saham (shareholders’ agreement, SHA) often assume it overrides everything else. In an Indonesian PT, that is not how it works.

Key takeaways

  • The articles of association (anggaran dasar) bind the company and its organs. A shareholders’ agreement, in principle, binds only the signatories.
  • Where they conflict, corporate acts such as shareholder resolutions are assessed under the Company Law and the articles. A breach of the SHA generally gives rise to a contractual claim between shareholders, not automatic invalidity of the company’s act.
  • Rights that matter to investors, such as share-transfer restrictions, higher quorums and director-nomination rights, should also be written into the articles where the Company Law allows.

Two documents, two functions

The articles of association form part of a PT’s deed of establishment and set out, among other things, its name and domicile, purpose and objectives, capital, number and classes of shares, and the procedures for shareholder meetings and for appointing directors and commissioners. The General Meeting of Shareholders (RUPS) decides amendments and, depending on the change, must approve them or notify the Minister of Law.

An SHA is an agreement between shareholders, and sometimes the company, that governs their relationship in more detail: funding obligations, veto rights over certain decisions, exit mechanisms, deadlock resolution, confidentiality and non-compete undertakings. As a contract, it binds its parties as law (Article 1338 of the Civil Code) and, in principle, does not bind third parties (Article 1340).

What happens when they conflict

A common scenario: the SHA gives the investor a veto over capital increases. The articles require only an ordinary quorum and majority. The founders, who hold the majority, convene a shareholders’ meeting and approve a capital increase without the investor’s consent.

The validity of that resolution is assessed against the Company Law and the articles. If the quorum and procedure in the articles were met, the resolution is, in principle, valid as a corporate matter. The investor can still sue the founders for breach of the SHA, for example for damages or performance of specific obligations, but that claim is contractual and does not automatically annul the resolution. Resolving it also takes time, while the capital structure has already changed.

An SHA position is therefore strongest when the articles support it.

Provisions to mirror in the articles

The Company Law allows the articles to contain several mechanisms investors commonly ask for:

  • Share-transfer restrictions. The articles may require shares to be offered first to other shareholders, prior approval from a company organ and/or approval from a competent authority before shares are transferred (Article 57). Without this, a right of first refusal in the SHA is difficult to enforce against the company.
  • Higher quorums and majorities. The Company Law sets minimum quorums and voting thresholds for shareholder meetings, but the articles may set higher ones (including Articles 86, 88 and 89). This can create a corporate-level veto.
  • Share classes. The articles may create share classes with particular rights, for example the right to nominate members of the board of directors or board of commissioners (Article 53).

Some terms are better left in the SHA: exit valuation, call and put options, confidentiality, non-compete undertakings, and deadlock mechanisms. These are commercial and often should not be public through the articles.

Other common problems

  • The company is not a party. If the SHA places obligations on the company, such as providing information to investors, the company should sign it, or the obligation should be framed as a shareholder undertaking to exercise voting rights.
  • Nominee arrangements. Agreements stating that shares in a PT are owned for and on behalf of another person are prohibited by Article 33 of Law No. 25 of 2007 on Investment and are void by law. An SHA cannot be used to disguise ownership.
  • Language. Agreements involving an Indonesian party must be in Bahasa Indonesia and may be bilingual. Failure to comply has underpinned disputes over agreement validity.
  • Dispute forum. The SHA should set the governing law and forum, such as arbitration, with the understanding that disputes over the validity of corporate acts may still go to court.

Next steps

Before signing an SHA, prepare a table comparing each key right in the SHA with the articles. For each right, decide whether it can remain contractual or needs to be mirrored in the articles. Then schedule the amendment of the articles as part of completion, not afterwards.

ReksaLegal prepares and aligns shareholders’ agreements and articles of association for funding rounds and joint ventures. Contact us at reksalegal.com or admin@reksalegal.com.

Legal references: Law No. 40 of 2007 on Limited Liability Companies (incl. Arts. 15, 19, 21, 53, 57, 86, 88, 89) as amended; Civil Code Arts. 1320, 1338, 1340; Law No. 25 of 2007 on Investment Art. 33; Law No. 24 of 2009 Art. 31 and Government Regulation No. 63 of 2019. Position as at 22 October 2026. Author: Sri Purnama.

General information only, not legal advice.

Author: Sri Purnama · Law stated as at: 5 November 2026

General information, not legal advice. For advice on your situation, contact ReksaLegal.

Need help with Contracts & Corporate?

Tell us about your situation. We reply within one business day and set out the scope and an itemised fee before any work begins.

Book a consultation